Top Used Cars for Gas Mileage

Think about it: if you’re dedicated to living an admirable, environmentally friendly lifestyle by recycling and using canvas bags for grocery shopping, you need a fuel-efficient vehicle to support your efforts.
Luckily, the team at Andy Mohr Automotive has rounded up our picks for the top used cars for gas mileage that are ideal for any driver near Indianapolis, Plainfield, and Bloomington, Indiana. So, if you’re ready to finally get behind the wheel of a green machine that’s committed to sipping on fuel, take a look at our choices of gas-conserving rides that fit your unique way of life.
Ford Focus
Ford has a habit of designing a variety of vehicles to fit various lifestyles. The Ford Focus is nothing short of a fuel-efficient companion, offering a lineup of engines that provide a harmonious blend of power and efficiency.
When all is said and done, a used Ford Focus achieves an EPA-estimated 30 city/40 highway MPG when equipped with a 1.0L EcoBoost® engine.
Plus, depending on the specific Ford Focus model you choose, you’ll have a choice between a manual or automatic transmission. That way, you’ll tailor the feel of every drive to suit your performance preferences.
Chrysler Pacifica Hybrid
The Chrysler Pacifica Hybrid is a standout option in the minivan category, offering versatility, advanced features, and excellent fuel efficiency. This plug-in hybrid model allows drivers to travel up to 32 miles on all-electric power before the gas-powered V6 engine engages.
After transitioning to the gas engine, the Pacifica Hybrid achieves an estimated 30 MPG in combined city/highway driving, making it one of the most efficient options for families needing a spacious and reliable vehicle.
Beyond its fuel efficiency, the Pacifica Hybrid is known for its advanced technology and safety features. The cabin comfortably seats up to seven passengers, with ample cargo space and the convenience of Chrysler’s innovative Stow ’n Go seating system. This system offers exceptional versatility for both passenger and cargo configurations, making it a convenient feature for families and individuals who need flexible interior space.
Toyota Prius
It’s no secret that the Toyota Prius has earned some serious recognition for its fuel efficiency. This hybrid roadster has claimed its place as one of the top used cars for gas mileage through its iconic silhouette and remarkable architecture.
For example, a used Toyota Prius features a 0.25 drag coefficient, which helps this cruiser obtain impressive fuel efficiency numbers—an EPA-estimated 57 MPG combined, to be specific.
Plus, EV, Eco, and Power buttons allow you to select the degree of fuel efficiency you want most. If you’re really looking to up the ante on your car’s gas-saving skills, select EV mode, and your used Toyota Prius will use only electric power to move you over the road.
Honda Fit
Like the other vehicles on our top used cars for gas mileage lineup, a used Honda Fit boasts streamlined style, interior practicality, and plenty of fuel-sipping prowess.
Certain model years provided in our used car inventory earn their claim to fame with an EPA-estimated 33 city/40 highway MPG—that’s efficiency assurance to begin your next spontaneous road trip with confidence, knowing that you’re in the driver’s seat of an environmentally minded vehicle.
Kia Soul
The Kia Soul stands out in the subcompact SUV segment with its unique boxy design, practicality, and budget-friendly pricing. It offers a high fuel economy, with the 2.0L engine delivering up to 29 MPG in the city and 35 MPG on the highway, depending on the model and trim level chosen. Its affordability and impressive efficiency make it a great option for individuals and small families seeking an economical and stylish ride.
Inside, the Kia Soul boasts a surprisingly spacious cabin with a high roofline, allowing for excellent headroom and versatile cargo storage. The rear seats can fold flat to expand the cargo area, easily accommodating larger items.
Chevrolet Cruze
Fuel-efficient cruising is easy at the helm of a used Chevy Cruze. By hopping inside certain model years and trim levels of this compact sidekick, you’ll reap the benefits of an EPA-estimated 29 city/39 highway MPG in manual models.
Even if you want a gas-conserving ride, it doesn’t mean that you should skimp on style. This sedan offers a sophisticated cabin that’s filled with soft materials, eye-catching accents, and lots of room for all your friends to stretch out.
Nissan Versa
Last but certainly not least is the used Nissan Versa. From its potent engine to its sturdy automatic transmission and everything in between, you’ll find all the essentials for an enjoyable road trip inside this compact sedan.
When it comes to fuel efficiency, a used Nissan Versa earns an EPA-estimated 27 city/35 highway MPG with manual transmission, which means you’ll avoid making frequent stops to fill up your tank while you’re focusing on making it to your destination.
Honda Accord
The Honda Accord is a well-regarded midsize sedan known for its reliability, performance, and efficiency. Depending on your chosen model, the Honda Accord Hybrid offers a remarkable fuel economy of up to 46 MPG in the city and 41 MPG on the highway, making it an excellent choice for those prioritizing lower fuel costs and reduced environmental impact.
Meanwhile, the standard Accord with a gas engine achieves an impressive 29 MPG in the city and 37 MPG on the highway, ensuring strong performance across all trims. The Accord’s reputation for longevity and low maintenance costs makes it a favorite among families and professionals alike. Its hybrid model offers a refined and quiet driving experience, while the gas-powered versions provide dynamic handling and responsive acceleration.
Browse Our Best Fuel Economy Used Car Inventory!
Andy Mohr Automotive is committed to helping drivers near Indianapolis, Plainfield, and Bloomington, IN, locate the fuel-efficient automobile that matches their eco-friendly attitude. Now that you know more about some of the top used cars for gas mileage available at our dealerships, it’s time to test them out yourself. Contact us to schedule a test drive on the model that piqued your interest.